# Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years - Page 5 - Politalk.ca

Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »

It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
al_keda
Posts: 1374
Joined: Tue May 14, 2024 7:20 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by al_keda »

I hope there is a comparison between our guy running things and their guy.

Night and day difference.
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »



“Imagine a Prime Minister who walks Canadians through the plan. Here is what we are trying to fix. Here is why this approach makes sense. Here is what success looks like. Here is when you should expect to feel it. Here is what might go wrong.

That kind of transparency does not weaken authority. It builds it. And it’s so different than anything else we’ve seen before.

In my work asking people questions, I see how people respond when leaders explain their thinking in plain language. Even skeptics become more patient and some opponents soften when they feel informed rather than managed. People are far more willing to grant room to manoeuvre when they understand the destination.”
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »

Leadership is not something that comes naturally to some people but the ones that are best at it are methodical and disciplined. When you see it you know and people gravitate towards competence and results. Not bluster and tired empty rituals. When warning orders are issued that are concise, direct and have limited achievable goals and THEN build on the results and see who is good at what and delegate accordingly the whole tenor of conversations change.

It's no longer becomes what can you get out of this or what can you do for me to what can we do to push this venture forward and accelerate the trend.
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »

It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »



Operation Nanuk 2026: While the DND touted this major exercise (February–April 2026) as a success in projecting forces across the Arctic (0:18–1:57), the video argues the CAF's overall track record remains mixed.
Operation Global Resolve Failures: In contrast to the official success narrative, an earlier exercise in Alaska saw approximately 60–70 soldiers suffer frostbite during a temperature drop to -43°C (2:16–2:44). The video highlights concerns regarding a lack of transparency from DND leadership following this incident (2:52–3:25).
Equipment Shortfalls: The video criticizes the reliability of modern military gear, specifically citing the failure of the General Purpose Sleeping Bag Systems (GPSBS) in 2024, which forced troops to revert to older 1960s-era models (3:45–4:13).
Proposed Solutions:
Leveraging Indigenous Expertise: The narrator advocates for the military to seek guidance from indigenous communities who have lived in the Arctic year-round (4:17–4:23).
Utilizing Traditional Materials: Research shows that natural materials like caribou hides provide superior insulation due to hollow hair follicles (4:24–4:37). The video suggests that collaborating with Inuit and northern communities to hunt caribou and establish a cottage industry for cold-weather gear could provide a sustainable, effective solution for the CAF (4:45–5:09).
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »

It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »

Ottawa seeks options to replace Canadian military’s aging fleet of tanks
The Department of National Defence has asked industry to outline:

Upgrade paths for Canada’s current Leopard 2A4 tanks

Full replacement options with modern main battle tanks

Associated heavy direct‑fire systems, including recovery and combat‑support vehicles

“Medium cavalry vehicles” to complement a future common light‑armoured fleet

This is part of a broader modernization push under the Army’s Inflection Point document, which warned that decades of focusing on counter‑insurgency left Canada with serious gaps in heavy armour.

What tanks are likely to be considered?
The RFI doesn’t name models, but based on what’s on the global market, likely contenders include:

Leopard 2A7+ (Germany) — logical upgrade path

K2 Black Panther (South Korea) — already pitched to other NATO states

Challenger 3 (UK) — though production is limited

M1A2 SEPv4 Abrams (USA) — though Canada may avoid U.S. options for industrial reasons


$8.5 million per unit


US$27.36 million per unit
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »



The U.S. Army canceled the deployment of the 2nd Armored Brigade Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division—a force of about 4,000 soldiers—that had been scheduled to rotate into Poland as part of Operation Atlantic Resolve.

Key details:

A Defense Department memo issued May 1 halted the deployment.

Advance elements already in Poland have been ordered to return to the United States.

The brigade was supposed to replace the 3rd Armored Brigade Combat Team, continuing the regular rotation of heavy forces in Eastern Europe.

The Pentagon has not publicly explained the cancellation.
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
User avatar
Dr Strangelove
Posts: 13686
Joined: Wed May 08, 2024 4:50 pm

Re: Carney Calls on Canada for Citizens' Army, as NATO Warns of Russian Attack Within 5 Years

Post by Dr Strangelove »



Procurement Process: The government has issued a 'Request for Information' (RFI) to industry, allowing two months for potential suppliers to propose solutions—either upgrading the existing Leopard 2 fleet or constructing entirely new vehicles (0:05-0:30, 1:24-1:30).
Fleet Status: The Canadian Army currently possesses 76 Leopard 2 tanks, including 34 training-dedicated 2A4s, 20 combat-capable 2A4Ms, and 20 advanced 2A6Ms (1:37-2:06).
Restructuring & Centralization: Army Commander Lieutenant General Michael Wright has initiated a plan to consolidate the tank fleet at CFB Edmonton to establish a centralized maintenance facility. This move affects the Regular Force armoured cavalry regiments, which will now rotate through Edmonton for training, relying on simulators and alternative platforms at their home bases (2:08-3:10).
Historical Context: The video contrasts current procurement challenges with Canada’s historical tank acquisitions, such as the Centurion tanks in the 1950s and the Leopard 1 fleet purchased in the 1970s (3:31-4:03).
Timeline Concerns: While current refurbishment plans aim to keep the Leopard 2 platforms viable until 2035, the slow pace of Canadian military procurement creates uncertainty regarding the delivery of a replacement fleet (0:40-0:55, 5:04-5:16).
It can be dangerous to believe things just because you want them to be true. - Sagan
Cynicism is acceptance
Post Reply